Handmaid’s Tale

by Margaret Atwood
Why Banned: Bad for Children

Banning History:

Published in 1986, in the midst of President Reagan’s presidency and a renewed women's liberation movement, The Handmaid's Tale is a frightening work of speculative fiction. Atwood presents a dystopian society in which women have been stripped of all forms of agency and reduced to a strict cast system of feminine archetypes, separating the duties of wife, housekeeper and child-bearer between three individuals. Due to its darkly satirical envisioning of Christianity and graphic representation of female sexual experiences, the work has been controversial since its publishing and in 2009, was number 88th on the ALA's list of most challenged books. The novel's inclusion in school curricula is frequently criticized, the most consistent reason being for its depictions of sex. Gene Kennedy, a school director at Ringgold high school in Pennsylvania, said that the book is “garbage”. This was a statement made during a 2014 review of the novels removal from the school library. Despite the protests of the school's board of directors, the book remained off the shelves. Over the past decade, the book has received near-yearly challenges in schools across North America. In the author's home country of Canada, complaints were made by parents of senior students at Lawrence Park Collegiate of Toronto. The allegations were made fearing that the violence, anti-Christian overtones and "sexual degradation" present in the novel violated school polices requiring respect and tolerance between students. The most recent reported challenge occurred at Grimsley High School In Guilford County, NC for being "sexually explicit, violently graphic and morally corrupt" while other parents felt it of was "detrimental to Christian values.” Despite this, the reading was retained for its intended Advanced Placement course.

Author Bio

Margaret Atwood was born November 18th, 1939 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. Her father Carl Atwood was a professor and her mother Margaret Killam was a nutritionist. Due to her father’s studies in zoology and entomology, the Atwood family would spend half of each year removed from society in the surrounding woods of Ontario, where her father studied the damage insects inflicted upon Canadian forests. This early connection with environmentalism carried through Atwood's childhood and into her written work. A recurring aspect of The Handmaid’s Tale is the devastation wrought on the environment by humans, pollution and nuclear radiation has rendered large portions of America and its human inhabitants infertile, leading to food shortages and an extremely low birth rate. In addition to their unconventional living situation, Atwood’s family had a very modern dynamic, in that both her parents shared domestic duties and her mother had no issue with the rugged necessities of their life in the forest. Through her parents, Atwood was instilled with a certainty that women were equal to men and to not blindly follow societally imposed limitations of her gender. This would lead to her pursuing a higher education in writing. In 1961, after her schooling finished, she published her first book, a collection of poems entitled Double Persephone. She would continue to publish narrative texts and it was during a stint in Berlin in the mid 1980s that she began work on The Handmaid’s Tale, partially inspired by works such as Orwell's 1984 and Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451. Atwood stated that for years she felt that the premise of The Handmaid's Tale was too ridiculous, until she began noticing that “a lot of the things I thought I was more or less making up were now happening”. Midway through the book’s completion, she returned to Canada, where she finished the novel. After two years of steady work, The Handmaid's Tale was published in February, 1986. Despite the controversy, The Handmaid’s Tale was largely well-received and won the Governor General’s Award in 1986.
Atwood has little to say about the controversies surrounding The Handmaid’s Tale, beyond that during the writing process she "did not wish to be accused of dark, twisted inventions, or of misrepresenting the human potential for deplorable behavior.” To achieve this, she purposefully chose only pre-existing cultural behaviors as the basis for her dystopia and only things that could be achieved with available technology, making this future have a chilling sense of realism.

Discussion Questions

1) At the end of the novel, a reveal is made about the context of the narrative. Did this change your interpretation of the novel as a whole?

2) Margaret Atwood has referred to this book as "speculative fiction". Weighing the current cultural environment and technology to that of the mid-eighties, do you think a similar future is more or less possible? Why or why not?

3) A recurring reason for this book's numerous challenges is its sexual content. How do you feel sex is portrayed throughout the novel? Is it positive or negative?

4) In Gilead society, women are not allowed to read; words have instead been replaced by symbols. How does this compare to the rise of our current logo-driven or “emoji” culture?